WASHINGTON
— The White House has pressured the chief executives of some of
America’s largest energy, financial and industrial corporations into
canceling plans to attend an international economic forum in Russia to be hosted by President Vladimir V. Putin this month, the latest effort to isolate Moscow in retaliation for its intervention in Ukraine.
The
top executives of such giants as Alcoa, Goldman Sachs, PepsiCo, Morgan
Stanley, ConocoPhillips and other multinational companies with business
in Russia have either pulled out of the conference or plan to do so
after an intensive lobbying campaign by President Obama’s advisers. Corporate officials predicted that nearly every American C.E.O. will now skip the forum in St. Petersburg.
The
personal telephone calls from White House officials and cabinet
secretaries have put the executives in an awkward position because they
do not want to run afoul of the Obama administration, but they are
acutely aware that Mr. Putin takes attendance at this event, which has
become an important showcase for him on the world stage. Hoping to avoid
alienating Mr. Putin at the risk of jeopardizing their operations and
tens of thousands of employees in Russia, several companies are sending
lower-level executives based in Moscow or Europe to the meeting from May
22 to 24.
The
St. Petersburg forum, styled as Russia’s answer to the annual economic
meeting in Davos, Switzerland, has thus become the latest battleground
in the geopolitical contest of wills between Mr. Obama and Mr. Putin
over the fate of Ukraine.
Although
sanctions imposed by Mr. Obama do not legally preclude American
companies from sending representatives to the gathering, administration
officials have told the top executives that personally participating
would make them propaganda tools for Mr. Putin, who could use their
presence to refute the notion that he has been isolated internationally.
The
pullout could be embarrassing for Mr. Putin, who attends the forum. As
of Monday, the forum’s website was still trumpeting the participation of
some American executives who now plan to skip the session. A picture of
Lloyd Blankfein, the chairman and chief executive of Goldman Sachs, for
instance, was shown on the site even as a company executive privately
said “there’s almost zero chance” he will go unless the Ukraine
situation suddenly reverses course.
Among
the top administration officials who have been working the telephones
are Valerie Jarrett, the president’s senior adviser and liaison to
business; Jacob J. Lew, the Treasury secretary; Penny Pritzker, the
commerce secretary; and Jeffrey D. Zients, the national economic
adviser.
“They’ve
basically been saying, ‘We’re not telling you what to do, but it
wouldn’t look good,’ ” said an executive at one of the companies who
received such a call, and who, like others, declined to be named to
avoid offending either side in the dispute.
Some
industry officials privately expressed frustration at being caught in
the middle, and argued that cutting off business ties would worsen
relations between the United States and Russia rather than improve them.
They said European or Asian competitors may simply fill the void.
“Nobody wants to get caught on the wrong side of anybody in this if they
can help it,” said one such official. “Some companies are trying to do
their best to avoid getting trapped in this minefield.”
The
White House said American government officials will not attend the St.
Petersburg forum this year. “Obviously, companies will have to make
their own decisions, but we believe that the most senior business
executives traveling to Russia to make high-profile appearances with
Russian government officials at events such as this would send an
inappropriate message,” said Laura Lucas Magnuson, a White House
spokeswoman.
The
situation has left many corporate executives anxious. At a closed
meeting in Moscow of the American Chamber of Commerce in Russia last
week, representatives of United States firms expressed aggravation at
being penalized either way. “The understanding is that those that choose
to go will be on the Obama administration’s dog list,” concluded a
participant’s summary of the session. “One U.S. executive at today’s
meeting warned that Putin/Kremlin will closely watch which U.S. C.E.O.’s
cancel and their Russia business will be impacted.”
The
situation reflects a turnaround from a year ago, when the Obama
administration encouraged participation to strengthen trade ties. The
chief executives of General Electric, Deere & Company, Citigroup,
MetLife, Alcoa, ConocoPhillips, ExxonMobil, Visa, Chevron, Hill &
Knowlton Strategies and Cisco Systems attended last year.
Few,
if any, of them will be there this month. Ryan Lance, chief executive
of ConocoPhillips, has decided to skip the event, according to the
company. Klaus Kleinfeld, chief executive of Alcoa and chairman of the
United States-Russia Business Council, canceled plans to attend on
Friday, citing “the U.S. government’s requirements.”
Boeing,
which depends on Russia for much of its titanium, has registered Dennis
A. Muilenburg, the chief operating officer, but a spokesman, John Dern,
said, “We are certainly watching developments day by day.” ExxonMobil
and Chevron would not say Monday whether their chief executives plan to
return this year.
Jeffrey
Immelt, the chief executive of G.E., never planned to go this year, a
company spokeswoman said. Rachel Potts, a spokeswoman for Caterpillar,
said the company “currently plans” to be represented this year by the
group president, Donald James Umpleby III, but added, “We’re monitoring
the situation closely.”
For
some companies, the decision has been harder than for others. Industry
officials said the situation has tormented PepsiCo, which made $4.9
billion in Russia last year, making it the company’s second-largest
market, and Cargill, the agricultural producer that has invested more
than $1 billion in Russia and has more than 3,000 employees there.
Pepsi’s chief executive, Indra Nooyi, abruptly canceled last week,
citing a scheduling conflict. Cargill has not disclosed its plans.
The
situation comes at a delicate time for Morgan Stanley, which is in the
middle of selling its commodities business to Rosneft, the largest
Russian state-owned oil company, whose chief executive, Igor I. Sechin,
is the subject of sanctions by the Obama administration. James Gorman,
Morgan Stanley’s chief executive, canceled his plans to travel to St.
Petersburg on Friday.
“A
lot of us waited,” said an executive at one firm that received a call
from the White House, “but the situation’s not getting better.”
Clifford Krauss contributed reporting from Houston, and Andrew E. Kramer from Moscow.
No comments:
Post a Comment