Saturday, May 10, 2014

EU Sees Political Deal On ESM And Bail-Ins By June

Today’s AM fix was USD 1,289.00, EUR 933.25 and GBP 762.54 per ounce.
Yesterday’s AM fix was USD 1,291.25, EUR 926.03 and GBP 761.13 per ounce.
Gold fell $0.20 or 0.016% yesterday to $1,289.20/oz. Silver slipped $0.14 or 0.73% to $19.17/oz.
Spot Gold Price in U.S. Dollars – 5 Days (Thomson Reuters)
Gold held steady around $1,290/oz today, underpinned by strong chart support. Unless, it rises by some 1% today, it is set to fall marginally for a second week. Traders are likely to be nervous about being short gold due to the “event risk” given the significant continuing geopolitical tension due to the crisis in Ukraine.
Despite the losses this week, the fundamentals remain sound. One of these key fundamentals are still ultra loose monetary policies. This week heard confirmation that the monetary policies of the Federal Reserve, ECB and Bank of England are set to remain ultra loose and in the ECB’s case may become even looser.
ECB president Mario Draghi said yesterday that the bank was ready to take action next month to boost the euro zone economy if updated inflation forecasts merited such a move.
The dollar extended gains against the euro today after posting its biggest one-day drop in nearly two months yesterday, as investors positioned for more dovish monetary policies from the European Central Bank and the increasing possibility of ECB currency printing and debt monetisation.
Gold appears to be consolidating and has found solid support at its 100 day moving average at $1,287/oz – see chart below.
Gold rallied to three-week highs on Monday at $1,315/oz on the back of elevated tensions in Ukraine, but it failed to maintain those gains after Russian President Vladimir Putin said he was willing to negotiate with European officials over the crisis.

Spot Gold Price in U.S. Dollars – 10 Years (Thomson Reuters)
Pro-Moscow separatists in eastern Ukraine ignored a public call by Putin to postpone a referendum on self-rule, however, declaring they would go ahead on Sunday with a vote that could lead to war.
While tensions with Russia have abated, it appears to be the case of the calm before a possible  geopolitical storm.
Gold premiums in India, the world’s second biggest bullion consumer, slipped marginally this week.  Premiums remain elevated at nearly $100 per ounce, showing that demand remains robust despite  expectations of a relaxation in import curbs. The relaxation in import taxes is expected to lead a significant increase in official Indian demand again.
Among other precious metals, silver was up 0.1 percent at $19.15 an ounce, while spot platinum was down 0.6 percent at $1,424.40 an ounce and spot palladium was down 0.2 percent at $799.22 an ounce.
Platinum group metals prices have been supported by the geopolitical tension with Russia and the long running miners’ strike in major producer South Africa, currently in its sixteenth week.
Prudent buyers will continue to dollar cost average into precious metal allocations on weakness.
EU Sees Political Deal on ESM And Bail-Ins by June
EU finance ministers are nearing political agreement on how the EU’s firewall fund could provide direct aid to banks after bail-ins, Dutch Finance Minister and chairman of eurozone finance ministers, Jeroen Dijsselbloem has said.
The European Stability Mechanism’s (ESM) direct bank recapitalization tool and
bail-ins have been developing for nearly two years. Dijsselbloem said there was broad support for his latest proposal, which sets conditions for when and how bail-ins and the bank-aid tool will be usable in 2015.
“We made very good progress” Dijsselbloem told reporters in Brussels after he led a meeting of his euro-area counterparts. The plan “will allow ministers to seek, where necessary, a parliamentary mandate in view of a political decision which we can then take before our next regular meeting of June 19,” he is quoted as saying by Bloomberg.
A long-running debate over backstops has direct implications for the success of the European Central Bank’s stress tests of 128 banks – many of which are still vulnerable.
Dijsselbloem said the planned guidelines will be most important during the year before the start of new EU rules in 2016 on how to assign losses to creditors at failing banks.
The EU’s bailout fund, the European Stability Mechanism (ESM) , could directly invest in a troubled bank next year, after 8% of the bank’s total liabilities are written off, Dijsselbloem said.
The bloc’s leaders agreed in 2012 that the ESM must have the option of directly buying a stake in a troubled bank to break the “doom loop” that binds indebted governments to the unstable banks they are trying to prop up.
Jeroen Dijsselbloem, who chairs meetings of eurozone finance ministers, said ministers agreed the ESM should be able to bail out banks next year after the option of raising money from “private investors” or the government failed.
He again failed to mention that money would also be “raised” from savers and depositors.
This means the direct investment of the euro zone bailout fund in a troubled euro zone bank would be a last-resort measure after all other options, including depositor bail-in, were exhausted.
Once the Bank Resolution and Recovery Directive is fully in force from the start of 2016, not only a bank’s shareholders but also bondholders and even large depositors will lose money before government or euro zone money could be used to save a bank from collapse.
It seems likely that in the event of another Northern Rock, Bear Stearns or worse Lehman Brothers like systemic crisis that the EU would expedite the ESM and bail-in legislation.
ConclusionEU politicians and bureaucrats say that this is part of the effort to prevent another debt crisis flare-up.
Critics fear that bail-ins are another way of protecting indebted large banks at the expense of already hard pressed savers and depositors including small and medium size businesses – the backbone of most economies.
EU policy-makers call this a bail-in, contrasting it with using taxpayers’ money to bail out failing banks.
There appears to be a complete failure to consider and understand that there is a risk of creating a new “doom loop” between indebted governments, creditors who are wiped out and some who are turned into debtors and unstable banks. There is also a failure to realise that bail-ins will likely result in capital controls and all the attendant negative consequences that they have on an economy.
Not to mention, the dreadful effect bail-ins would have on already fragile consumer and business sentiment is struggling Eurozone economies.
As our extensive research points out, bail-ins create a risk of runs on banks – thereby making indebted banks even more insolvent and entrenching the “doom loop” that policy makers are attempting to prevent.
The coming bail-in regimes will pose real challenges and risks to investors and of course depositors – both household and business.
Return of capital, rather than return on capital will assume far greater importance.


Debunking the Widespread Economic Myth that War Is Good for the Economy

Repairing the “Broken Window” Fallacy

Extremely influential economists like Paul Krugman and Martin Feldstein promote the myth that war is good for the economy.
Talking heads like senior Washington Post political columnist David Broder parrot this idea.
Their ideas are based on the main economic myth encouraging war … the “broken window” fallacy.
Economist Art Carden demolishes the myth:

This graphic illustrates the concept:Broken Window Fallacy
Source: BestAccountingDegrees.net 
David R. Henderson – associate professor of economics at the Naval Postgraduate School in Monterey, California and previously a senior economist with President Reagan’s Council of Economic Advisers - writes:Is military conflict really good for the economy of the country that engages in it? Basic economics answers a resounding “no.”***Money not spent on the military could be spent elsewhere.This also applies to human resources. The more than 200,000 U.S. military personnel in Iraq and Afghanistan could be doing something valuable at home.Why is this hard to understand? The first reason is a point 19th-century French economic journalist Frederic Bastiat made in his essay, “What Is Seen and What Is Not Seen.” Everyone can see that soldiers are employed. But we cannot see the jobs and the other creative pursuits they could be engaged in were they not in the military.The second reason is that when economic times are tough and unemployment is high, it’s easy to assume that other jobs could not exist. But they can. This gets to an argument Bastiat made in discussing demobilization of French soldiers after Napoleon’s downfall. He pointed out that when government cuts the size of the military, it frees up not only manpower but also money. The money that would have gone to pay soldiers can instead be used to hire them as civilian workers. That can happen in three ways, either individually or in combination: (1) a tax cut; (2) a reduction in the deficit; or (3) an increase in other government spending.***Most people still believe that World War II ended the Great Depression …. But look deeper.***The government-spending component of GNP went for guns, trucks, airplanes, tanks, gasoline, ships, uniforms, parachutes, and labor. What do these things have in common? Almost all of them were destroyed. Not just these goods but also the military’s billions of labor hours were used up without creating value to consumers. Much of the capital and labor used to make the hundreds of thousands of trucks and jeeps and the tens of thousands of tanks and airplanes would otherwise have been producing cars and trucks for the domestic economy. The assembly lines in Detroit, which had churned out 3.6 million cars in 1941, were retooled to produce the vehicles of war. From late 1942 to 1945, production of civilian cars was essentially shut down.And that’s just one example. Women went without nylon stockings so that factories could produce parachutes. Civilians faced tight rationing of gasoline so that U.S. bombers could fly over Germany. People went without meat so that U.S. soldiers could be fed. And so on.These resources helped win the war—no small issue. But the war was not a stimulus program, either in its intentions or in its effects, and it was not necessary for pulling the U.S. out of the Great Depression. Had World War II never taken place, millions of cars would have been produced; people would have been able to travel much more widely; and there would have been no rationing. In short, by the standard measures, Americans would have been much more prosperous.Today, the vast majority of us are richer than even the most affluent people back then. But despite this prosperity, one thing has not changed: war is bad for our economy. The $150 billion that the government spends annually on wars in Iraq and Afghanistan (and, increasingly, Pakistan) could instead be used to cut taxes or cut the deficit. By ending its ongoing wars … the U.S. government … would be developing a more prosperous economy.***Whatever other reasons there may be for war, strengthening the economy is never one of them.Indeed, we have thoroughly documented that war makes us poor.Postscript: While war is bad for us, it is very good for a handful of defense contractors and banksters who make huge sums from fighting or financing unnecessary war.

Mac Faber: I’m Worried About A Crisis Bigger Than 2008













I don’t think the economy is recovering at all, says Marc Faber, The Gloom, Boom & Doom Report, explaining why he thinks there’s more pain ahead for the economy, and why stocks and bonds will go down at the same time.

Russia Ukraine Update, No Bank “Too Big to Jail”, IRS Official in Contempt of Congress & More!


http://usawatchdog.com/weekly-news-wr… - Even though Russia says it is backing off in Ukraine, the economic and psychological war is intensifying. Big headline in USA Today says “Putin Diffuses Tensions in Ukraine Crisis.” Putin says it is backing some troops off from the border, but NATO says there is “no evidence of withdrawal.” My sources say Russia will not do an overt invasion; it will just let Ukraine sink into chaos.An IRS official at the center of the IRS targeting scandal is now in contempt of Congress. The House voted to this week to hold Lois Lerner in contempt for not answering questions in the investigation over the IRS targeting conservative groups.Trey Gowdy has been picked to head up a committee to get to the Benghazi scandal where our Ambassador and three others were killed in a terrorist attack. Gowdy is a former federal prosecutor. The White House said the attack was “spontaneous” and did not have al-Qaeda ties. Both points are 100% false.Join Greg Hunter of USAWatchdog.com as he analyzes these stories and more in the Weekly News Wrap-Up.

London GOLD VAULTS EMPTY: Price Spike Ahead | Ferguson

IN THIS INTERVIEW:
- Physically deliverable gold futures contracts are coming Asian markets* ?1:10
- Manipulation: gold & silver price fluctuation limits will be implemented* ?6:30
- London gold vaults are empty, gold price spike ahead ?8:31
- Silver price will follow gold higher. At $19/oz, silver is a “bargain” ?16:55
- Federal Reserve “taper” and Friday’s job numbers* are lies ?23:10 
ABOUT OUR GUEST:
Known primarily by his nickname “Turd Ferguson,” Craig Hemke is the founder and editor of the popular TF Metals Report blog and podcast (http://TFMetalsReport.com), covering precious metals, the financial markets, and greater economic trends. A graduate of the University of Nebraska with a BS in Economics, Hemke was a licensed securities professional (Series 7) for nearly twenty years and has been an active commodity option trader since 1987. Hemke has been featured on The New York Times, The Wall Street Journal, Forbes, Market Watch, CNBC, among many other news stations.
SUBSCRIBE (It’s FREE!) to Reluctant Preppers, “Helping You Be Aware and Prepared” ?http://bit.ly/ReluctantPreppers
SUBSCRIBE (also FREE!) to “Finance and Liberty” for more interviews and financial insight ? http://bit.ly/Subscription-Link 
FINANCE AND LIBERTY:
Website ?http://FinanceAndLiberty.com
Like us on Facebook ?http://fb.com/FinanceAndLiberty
Follow us on Twitter ?http://twitter.com/Finance_Liberty
Google Plus ?http://Gplus.to/FinanceLiberty
Title and video graphics by Josiah Johnson Studios ?http://JosiahJohnsonStudios.com
Our sponsor Reluctant Preppers ?http://ReluctantPreppers.com*RESOURCES:
- Reuters, “?CME Group Inc plans to launch a physically deliverable gold futures contract in Asia” ?http://reut.rs/RmKNca
- Reuters, “UPDATE 3-CME mulls price fluctuation limits for gold, silver futures??” ?http://reut.rs/1g5stKF
- Jobs’ Numbers Friday, May 2, 2014: Bureau of Labor Statistics, “Employment Situation Summary” ?http://1.usa.gov/1kSW6Dl
- Federal Reserve tapers to $45 billion per month: Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System, “Press Release [April 30, 2014]” ?http://1.usa.gov/1mAM4pQ
- Phoenix Capital Research, “On Closer Look, the Jobs Report Was In Fact a Disaster” ?http://goo.gl/YMAhxi 
DISCLAIMER: The financial and political opinions expressed in this interview are those of the guest and not necessarily of “Finance and Liberty” or its staff. Opinions expressed in this video do not constitute personalized investment advice and should not be relied on for making investment decisions.

Friday, May 9, 2014

The economic recovery is founded on cheap credit and easy money – not real, sustainable growth, says economist

We can forgive Chancellor George Osborne for looking smug. His efforts seem to be paying off.
Wage increases are overtaking price rises. Unemployment is falling. House prices are soaring.
Consumers are in the shops again. Economists predict near-record growth, and the IMF says the UK is likely to be the fastest-growing economy in the developed world.
But actually, if you look more closely, these are all worrying signs.
Smug? We can forgive Chancellor George Osborne for looking smug. His efforts seem to be paying off.
Smug? We can forgive Chancellor George Osborne for looking smug. His efforts seem to be paying off.

This is fake, runaway growth, founded on cheap credit and easy money – not real, sustainable growth.
Interest rates have been kept at rock bottom for five years now, which is fine for an economy on its last legs but not one racing away.
And £375billion worth of virtual money has been created through quantitative easing. This is a hair-of-the-dog policy.
 

Starting in the Blair-Brown years, we had a huge party. The government spent wildly, as did consumers, all fuelled by cheap borrowing. It was a great party, until the money ran out.
But rather than suffer the hangover, we simply borrowed even more. That’s hardly ‘austerity’.
And when the inevitable hangover does come, it will be even worse.
We need to stop living in this fantasyland created by politicians and their hand-maidens, the financial regulators, and to start wising up to the things they don’t really want to tell you.
Warning: Dr Eamonn Butler has concerns about the economic recovery
Warning: Dr Eamonn Butler has concerns about the economic recovery

The first is to realise that the financial crisis was caused by government profligacy. When you are in a casino and the government is handing out free gaming chips and buying drinks at the bar, people are going to make some very bad bets.
And in the early 2000s, we did exactly that: buying new cars, big houses and a hugely expanded government that we simply could not afford.
Has the party stopped since the 2008 crash? Despite the ‘austerity’ talk, the government has hardly shrunk at all, and consumers are still borrowing to spend. We need to get real.
The Bank of England must raise borrowing rates and the government must slash its spending – and slash taxes on the back of that, allowing consumers to get by without getting deeper into debt and making it cheaper for firms to hire, invest and grow.
By 2018, public debt will be double where it stood under Labour.
The second thing is to restore sound money.
How easy it would be for all of us if, like the Bank of England, we had cash-creation machines in our basements. But like everything else, the more new money that is around, the less value it has.
That is why the pound has fallen so much and why foreign holidays are so expensive. Inflation is bound to pick up too, as all that quantitative easing eventually works through to prices.
The authorities are going to need real discipline to choke things off – but they must.
Third, we still need to fix the banks. All of that new, costly regulation has squeezed out small banks, leaving just a handful of too-big-to-fail giants – which can do what they like because there is no competition to restrain them.
We know where that landed us in 2007-08.
But this time, the government does not have any cash to bail them out. We need new banking competition, and fast.
Which is easy: just raise the solvency rules for bigger banks and they will soon break themselves into smaller ones.
There are many more things we must do, such as cut and simplify taxes, and remove obstructions to small-business growth. It is not going to be painless.
But if we want a real, sustainable recovery rather than raceaway growth that ends in an even bigger financial crash, we have to stop believing in the fantasy  that politicians are continuing to spin.
÷Dr Butler’s book, The Economics Of Success: 12 Things Politicians Don’t Want You To Know (Gibson Square £12.99,  e-book £8.99) Mail readers can order it free of postage from mailbookshop.co.uk or call 08444 724 157.
Dr Eamonn Butler is director of the Adam Smith Institute

30,000 lobbyists and counting: is Brussels under corporate sway?

From mobile phone charges to nations' interests, these shadowy agitators are estimated to influence 75% of European legislation
European parliament
Power point: the European parliament is subject to intense pressure from corporate interests, and many MEPs use their inside knowledge to take up lucrative lobbying positions when they quit. Photograph: Michele Tantussi/Getty Images
When the Polish MEP Róża Thun was elected five years ago, she thought the job would be fairly straightforward. She hadn't reckoned with the lobbyists.
Take mobile phone charges. She saw the fact that EU citizens pay eye-watering sums in other EU states as an anomaly that needed fixing. But it wasn't that simple. "We had telephone companies and lobbyists who started to invade us," she recalls. "They obviously didn't want to reduce roaming charges because it would hit them in the pocket."
To stroll around the vast, ugly and permanent building site that is Brussels' European district is to brush up against the power of the lobbies. Every office block, every glass and steel construction within a kilometre of the European commission, council and parliament is peopled by Europe's biggest corporate names.
Thousands of companies, banks, law firms, PR consultancies and trade associations are there to bend ears and influence the regulations and laws that shape Europe's single market, fix trade deals, and govern economic and commercial behaviour in a union of 507 million.
Lobbying is a billion-euro industry in Brussels. According to Corporate Europe Observatory, a watchdog campaigning for greater transparency, there are at least 30,000 lobbyists in Brussels, nearly matching the 31,000 staff employed by the European commission and making it second only to Washington in the concentration of those seeking to affect legislation. Lobbyists sign a transparency register run by the parliament and the commission, though it is not mandatory.
By some estimates, they influence 75% of legislation. In principle, lobbyists give politicians information and arguments during the decision-making process. In practice, the corridors of the parliament often teem with individuals, who meet MEPs in their offices or in open spaces such as the "Mickey Mouse bar" (nicknamed so because of the shape of its seats) inside the parliament.
They explain their concerns, provide a "position paper", and send in suggestions for amendments to legislative proposals. Of course, the final decision is taken by MEPs. But examples are legion of the tail wagging the dog.
Lobbying is such a crucial part of the climate in Brussels that it has spawned manuals, a documentary (Who Really Runs the EU?) and even "the worst lobby awards". Not surprisingly, the biggest movers and shakers agitate for the biggest industries with the most to gain – and lose – from European legislation.

Energy

David Cameron visits Total Oil shale drilling site David Cameron visits the Total Oil shale drilling site in Gainsborough, Lincolnshire in January. Photograph: Getty Images It is a fertile time to be an energy lobbyist in Brussels. Vladimir Putin's stranglehold on Europe's gas supplies and campaign to dismember Ukraine have thrust energy to the top of the international and European agenda.
When Barack Obama visited EU headquarters in March, he had stern words in public – and even stronger remarks in private, according to senior diplomats – for Europe's leaders, telling them they had to risk the wrath of their voters and go for fracking and shale gas to help immunise Europe against Russian blackmail.
In a letter to Downing St in November, Ivan Rogers, the UK's ambassador to the EU, laid out a strategy for leaning on the commission to get it to adopt a minimalist position on shale exploration, entailing no new EU legislation. A week later David Cameron wrote to the commission chief, José Manuel Barroso, insisting on the light-touch regulation.
America's shale revolution, entrenching low energy prices in the US, is having a big impact, leading to a bonanza for the fracking lobbies in Brussels.
From shale to climate-change policies, from car exhaust rules to renewables, from carbon-capture technologies to carbon-trading schemes, the energy lobby is highly active and successful in Brussels, with companies such as BP and Shell maintaining big operations aimed at shaping policy. "In a nutshell the energy-intensive lobbies say they are not competitive, especially vis-a-vis the US, because of shale and the low prices there," says an industry insider engaged in Brussels lobbying. "They argue that we're much too focused on renewables and climate change and that we should be much more open like the US."
The most effective lobbying in Brussels centres on the gamekeepers-turned-poachers, the revolving door of senior commission officials, diplomats, and MEPs who retire or quit public office and instantly take up offers to translate their contacts and inside knowledge into lucrative lobbying work, often by moving to an office across the street.
Take Jean de Ruyt, a Belgian who knows Brussels inside out. As ambassador to the EU, the career diplomat in effect ran Belgium's EU presidency four years ago, then retired, took up a job with a US law firm and is now a leading figure in the shale lobby.
His No 2 as ambassador is now chief of staff to Herman Van Rompuy, the president of the European council steering EU summits.
For the shale lobby, Ukraine and Putin may represent less of a crisis than a huge opportunity. "The Ukraine crisis is seen as a blessing, giving the shale-gas lobby the perfect chance to say if you want to get rid of dependence on Russian gas…" said Antoine Simon, who analyses the politics of the extractive industries for Friends of the Earth.

Tobacco

Woman smoking cigarette Lobbies in Brussels rushed to launch a counteroffensive against an EU tobacco directive. Photograph: Bernhard Classen/Alamy In February the EU approved a new tobacco directive, which is designed to make smoking less attractive, particularly to young people. The lobbies in Brussels did not scrimp on resources as they rushed to launch a counteroffensive. About 200 representatives of three of the biggest tobacco companies, Philip Morris International, British American Tobacco and Japan Tobacco, spent four weeks in the city, hogging hotels and spending more than €3m (£2.5m) on an action plan to weaken future regulation in two parts: persuading the European commission, and trying to convince MEPs and national governments.
Juan Páramo is a spokesman for Mesa del Tabaco, which represents the Spanish tobacco industry. He says he met Spanish MEPs "on various occasions" to explain the impact the directive would have on a "key" sector for Spain.
"Lobbies aren't how they are depicted in the movies, but you have to be careful with your strategies," says Andrés Perelló, a veteran socialist MEP and a member of the environment, public health and food safety committee. He is used to contending with industries relating to cars, fuel or medicine – which are all heavily exposed to regulatory changes – but he cannot think of a single industry that piles as much pressure on as the tobacco sector. He has no problem with lobbies when they stick to an "adequate" code of conduct. He has also rejected many of their manoeuvres. "We are always ready to have a dialogue, we don't feel pressurised by anybody," he says. Any time a lobbyist comes to see him is "totally transparent", he says, and one of his assistants always takes notes of these meetings. "To be clear," he adds.
Another MEP felt pressurised by the visits, which he says were "very cordial, and absolutely threatening". He says the lobbying did not affect his final vote. "It didn't taste good, but all of these procedures were legal," he says.
With something as sensitive as tobacco regulation, health associations act as a sort of anti-lobby. "Faced with the tremendous pressure of the tobacco monopolies, nurses have had to do something they were not at all used to: lobby for public health," says Francisco Rodríguez, president of Spain's national committee for the prevention of smoking.
Nonetheless, far from the influence of the ordinary channels, the map of pressures on an oligopolistic market as important as tobacco brings with it all kinds of intrigues behind the scenes. Confidential documents published by the Guardian in September shows how the giant of the sector, Philip Morris International, managed to postpone a vote by MEPs on the anti-smoking directive. "It was quite disgusting," says a high-level parliamentary source.

Diplomats

EU flags are seen out outside European commission headquarters in Brussels European Union flags outside the European commission headquarters in Brussels. Photograph: Yves Herman/Reuters One of the principal instruments in Brussels is diplomatic lobbying by member states. "The big embassies make a conscious effort to stay in contact with the strongest national delegations in parliament," says Florent Saint Martin, associate professor at Sciences Po, and a former MEP assistant who founded his own lobby consultancy. French MEPs receive detailed memos from the general secretariat of European affairs, an intergovernmental structure in Paris. A European affairs minister acts as the official correspondent with the European parliament.
"It's not so much as explaining how a vote should go," says Jean-Paul Gauzès, a French MEP and a financial specialist, "but about providing explanations on the texts which will be voted upon, and on defending the French interest in them."
"It's now possible for us to check in with an MEP to counter or amend a text we consider to be against our interests," says Alexis Dutertre, a permanent representative for France to the EU. "However, having 28 member states today is more difficult than having six, 12 or 15 to win a majority, or build a minority blocking other states with." Colleagues are supposed to spend as much time at the European parliament as in the European council, the bread-and-butter work of the European diplomat.
But the relationship between diplomat and MEP could be under pressure if the far-right parties gain seats at the European elections. "A Front National delegation will cause a really big problem because they are absent, to the point of being incontrollable," predicts Olivier Costa, director of political studies at the College of Europe in Bruges. Costa believes France's position is coming to resemble that of the UK, which has its fair share of Eurosceptic MPs.
"If the Front National win 20 seats, we'll only be able to count on some 50 useful MPs," says a French spokesman. "That will rank us alongside the next level down of populated countries, such as Spain and Poland."

Big tech

Facebook's data centre in Lulea A man walks past a logo created from pictures of Facebook users in the company's data centre in Lulea, in Swedish Lapland. Photograph: Jonathan Nackstrand/AFP/Getty Images One of the most prominent Brussels lobbyists is Erika Mann of Facebook. She spent 15 years with the German Social Democrats before walking through the "revolving door" to the lobbyists.
The latest figures in the official EU lobby register reveal Facebook spent less than €500,000 on lobbying in Brussels in 2012. That's surprisingly low: Facebook invested about $2.8m (£1.7m) in the first quarter of 2014 alone in the US. But US tech companies such Facebook, Google, Amazon and Microsoft rarely work as individual companies but more in corporate alliances. Jan-Philipp Albrecht, the German Green MEP responsible for the data protection reform act in parliament, estimates that more than half of companies that contact him are from the US. Other MEPs say the pressure is unprecedented.
In February 2013 the lobbyplag.eu website found some MEPs were not only inspired to make amendments suggested by US firms, but copied and pasted huge passages of text sent by lobbyists. Understanding who is doing the lobbying is not always straightforward: not all lobbyists are open about their allegiance – some even send their "suggestions" on paper with no clear letterhead.
Mann is more candid, always present in the debate, a regular on the public speaking and debate circuit, even turning up to European parliament sessions. It's hard to say how influential she has been after just a few months in the job. But one thing is for sure: the longer negotiations run on, the longer lobbyists kick about to try to influence proceedings. With data protection, as with everything in Brussels, "nothing is approved until everything is approved".

Consumer protection

Compared with these other formidable pressure groups, consumer protection is the poor relation of the lobbying family. The only voice for consumers in Brussels is Beuc, the Bureau of European Consumer Organisations. It has 35 employers and almost half its budget comes from the EU itself, making negotiation tricky.
If, for example, a consumer is tricked by a dodgy tour operator, there is little the EU can do. Beuc has acted in a few cases for consumers, mobile phone roaming charges and food labelling being among them. "Our task is to balance the industrial lobbies," says Johannes Kleis, a spokesman for Beuc. But in terms of fighting industry lobbies, it's David v Goliath. "One regret is that we have only recently started looking into consumer issues in financial services," Kleis says. While this may be handled at a nation-state level, Kleis says it's not enough "given that the market is global".