Friday, May 9, 2014
U.S. Subprime Loan Crisis: 2008 vs. 2014 – The Financial World Has A Short Memory
2008
– Subprime mortgage crisis
The
U.S. subprime
mortgage crisis was
a nationwide banking emergency that triggered the recession of 2008,
through subprime mortgage
delinquencies and foreclosures, resulting in the devaluation of the
attendant securities.
These mortgage-backed
securities (MBS)
and collateralized
debt obligations (CDO)
initially offered attractive rates of return due to the higher
interest rates on the mortgages; however, the lower credit quality
ultimately caused massive defaults.[1] While
elements of the crisis first became more visible during 2007, several
major financial institutions collapsed in September 2008, with
significant disruption in the flow of credit to businesses and
consumers and the onset of a severe global recession.[2]
There were
many causes of the crisis, with commentators assigning different
levels of blame to financial institutions, regulators, credit
agencies, government housing policies, and consumers, among
others.[3] A
proximate cause was the rise in subprime lending. The percentage of
lower-quality subprime
mortgagesoriginated
during a given year rose from the historical 8% or lower range to
approximately 20% from 2004 to 2006, with much higher ratios in some
parts of the U.S.[4][5] A
high percentage of these subprime mortgages, over 90% in 2006 for
example, were adjustable-rate
mortgages.[2] These
two changes were part of a broader trend of lowered lending standards
and higher-risk mortgage products.[2][6] Further,
U.S. households had become increasingly indebted, with the ratio of
debt to disposable
personal income rising
from 77% in 1990 to 127% at the end of 2007, much of this increase
mortgage-related.[7]
2014
– New US subprime boom – but this time it is for cars
According to
the credit agency Experian, the total amount owed on car finance in
the US had risen to $750 billion by late last year.
An estimated 36% of those loans have been made
to subprime borrowers. So are the banks storing up serious trouble
for the future – and maybe even another financial crisis?
American
subprime lending is back on the road
A few
short years ago, “subprime” was almost an expletive. During the
financial crisis, mortgages linked to subprime borrowers
– or those with poor credit history – caused devastating losses;
so much so that many asset managers declared they would never touch
subprime again.
But the financial world has a short memory,
particularly when easy money and innovation collide. In recent months
subprime lending has quietly staged a surprisingly powerful return,
not in relation to real estate, but another American passion –
cars. Some wonder how long it will be before this new boom causes
another wave of casualties, not just among naive consumers, but
investors too.
The Next Subprime ‘Time Bomb’ Is Ticking
(Here’s How You Could Profit from It)
Driving Toward a New Economic Cliff
I became aware of this potential time bomb last
year. A close friend was financially destroyed by the subprime
mortgage crisis. He is an investor and was overleveraged on more than
a dozen investment properties. He was finally forced to declare
bankruptcy to get out from under the mountain of debt.
Within a
week of the bankruptcy filing, he started getting letters from
companies like Wells Fargo (WFC)
and General Motors (GM).
While my friend was used to getting nasty letters from banks and
finance companies, these letters were very different. These were not
demand letters challenging his bankruptcy, threatening lawsuits or
anything the least bit negative. Believe it or not, these letters
were pre-approval letters for auto credit!
In fact, one financial company actually sent my
bankrupt friend a check for $30,000 to be used at any participating
auto dealer for the car of his choice. He took the check and bought a
used BMW.
Here
They Go Again: Wall Street Is Offering Debt-On-Debt-On-Debt!
Here’s how the daisy chain of debt
works— short form. LBO’s issue debt—loads of it. Leveraged
buyouts are now being priced at typical top-of-the-bubble ratios
of 10X cash flow (“adjusted EBITDA”). The portion of these
LBO debt towers that consists of bank term loans and revolver
facilities is sold to freshly minted financial conduits called CLOs
(for Collateralized Loan Obligations) which are not real companies
and which do not have any money!
No problem. What happens is that credit
hedge funds and Wall Street trading desk hit a computer
key, open a new spreadsheet window, wrap it in legal boilerplate,
provide this newly minted CLO with a credit line and then start
bidding for available LBO paper in the junk loan market. When
they have accumulated enough offers, they slice and dice the
resulting portfolio of LBO loans, and issue multiple tiers of debt–
with these new slices being rated from AAA to junk against the
loans listed on the spreadsheet.
So we now have a spreadsheet, a part-time
“portfolio manager” and hundreds of millions of the latest CLO
toxic waste. For 95 weeks running, there was no want of buyers
for this CLO issued paper. In its infinite wisdom, the Fed drove
interest rates on CDs and high quality paper to nearly zero—–so
the scramble for “yield” was on. Soon Grandpa was being forced to
buy a high yield mutual fund in order to pay the light bills….
Why We Are On The Verge Of Another Subprime Crisis
Do 2 Year Treasury Rates Guide the Gold Price?
by
GoldCore
Today’s AM fix was USD 1,291.25, EUR 926.03
and GBP 761.13 per ounce.
Yesterday’s AM fix was USD 1,311.00, EUR 942.08 and GBP 772.54 per ounce.
Yesterday’s AM fix was USD 1,311.00, EUR 942.08 and GBP 772.54 per ounce.
Gold fell $18.40 or 1.41% yesterday to
$1,289.40/oz. Silver slipped $0.25 or 1.28% to $19.31/oz.
After rising to near its highest level in three
weeks early yesterday at $1,315/oz, gold experienced its biggest
intraday price fall in three weeks yesterday, falling to $1,290/oz by
close of New York trading. Silver likewise retreated from the
$19.70/oz level to the $19.20/oz range.
The price weakness in the precious metals was
attributed to apparent de-escalation of tensions in the Ukraine
conflict after Russia promised that military exercises near the
eastern Ukrainian border would be scaled back, and Putin called for
separatists in the south-east of Ukraine to postpone an independence
referendum planned for May 11th.
Gold
and silver prices were also undermined by remarks from Janet
Yellen, the Fed Chair, who appeared yesterday before the U.S.
Congress in testimony about the U.S. economic outlook. While Yellen
didn’t say anything unexpected and reiterated that short-term
interest rates would remain near zero, her confirmation that the U.S.
economy would still be supported was interpreted as a positive for
risk assets.
The Governing Council of the European Central
Bank meets today in Brussels to decide whether to alter their closely
watched benchmark and deposit rates. Consensus economist estimates
indicate no changes, with the benchmark rate expected to stay at
0.25% and the deposit rate to stay at zero.
Gold is now trading again in a very narrow
trading range below $1,300/oz, and the market does not seem to want
to commit to push the gold price significantly in any one direction,
with investors appearing to be waiting on the sidelines.
Global
Macro 360
Today we feature incisive analysis on the gold price from Global Macro 360, the excellent new daily research service by economist, broadcaster, and author David McWilliams.
Today we feature incisive analysis on the gold price from Global Macro 360, the excellent new daily research service by economist, broadcaster, and author David McWilliams.
With the U.S. Dollar Index (DXY) down near a 2
year low and 10 year bond yields touching 2.6%, McWilliams highlights
that on previous occasions when the USD has touched these levels,
gold investors have got burnt, since their expectation that the USD
would weaken further, and that the gold price would rally, did not
materialise.
Likewise, there is no real conviction that 10
year yields will fall below 2.6%. Indeed, economic polls suggest that
the 10 year yield is expected to rise for the remainder of this year,
as is the shorter 2 year yield. Last time short-term rates spiked,
the gold price fell through $1200. This fear of rate hikes is likely
to be keeping bullish gold sentiment on the sidelines.
Note: The U.S. Dollar Index (DXY) measures the
dollar’s performance against a basket of six major currencies.
GoldCore has partnered with Global Macro 360 to
offer GoldCore readers a discounted 6 month or yearly subscription
membership to David McWilliam’s daily market insights. Follow
Global Macro 360 for more in depth economic analysis on the global
macro economy, including the gold price.
Paul B. Farrel: 10 Peaking Megabubbles Signal Impending Stock Crash http://investment
Yes, “the bull market may come to an end
any time,” warns Jeremy Grantham, founder of the $117 billion GMO
investment giant. An unpredictable collapse. Risky valuations, 10
bubbles peaking, and black swan megatrends: The bull “could be
derailed by disappointing global growth, profits sagging as deficits
are cut, a Russian miscalculation, or, perhaps most dangerous and
likely, an extreme Chinese slowdown.”
Yes,
Grantham’s hedging his near-term: Betting the S&P
500 could
rally past 2,250 before the 2016 presidential election, “depending
on what new ammunition the Fed can dig up.” But then, a black swan
will ignite “around the election or soon after, the market bubble
will burst” and “revert to its trend value, around half of its
peak or worse.”
Yes half. The S&P 500 will collapse to
about 1,125. This Fed-driven rally “will end badly.” Repeating
the dot-com losses of 2000-2003. Repeating Wall Street’s $10
trillion losses in 2007-2009.
Another GMO investment strategist, Edward
Chancellor, is even more skeptical of all these explosive short-term
risks. An expert in speculative bubble risks, Chancellor warns
investors of a ticking time bomb. His team tracks market bubbles.
They’re feeding off one another, gaining momentum, fusing,
expanding into a dangerous critical mass that can trigger and ignite
an S&P 500 explosion way before the 2016 elections.
“It is important for the Fed, as hard as it
is, to try to detect asset bubbles when they are forming,” Fed boss
Janet Yellen told the Senate last fall. Then two months ago, Yellen
said she didn’t see any speculative “excesses,” that stocks
were in line with “analysts estimates of future earnings.” Bad
news, Chancellor warns, future earnings are a “notoriously
unreliable measure of market value.” Besides, everyone knows the
Fed is has big “trouble identifying bubbles.”
New megabubbles bigger than ‘20s Gilded Age and ‘90s dot-com mania
While the Fed hesitates, GMO is clear. Why? The
formula is simple: “When an asset has moved two standard deviations
from its long-term real price trend” the markets are in a bubble.
That fits “the 1929 bubble, the Nifty-Fifty boom of the 1960s, and
the dot-com mania in the late 1990s.”
So Chancellor reviews the “typical features
of asset bubbles” throughout history, concluding “most of the
conditions under which earlier bubbles have appeared are present in
the U.S. markets today,” including “the soaring performance of
IPOs.” Long-term stock investors beware.
In short, despite Wall Street’s relentless
happy talk and optimism, another crash is dead ahead. A crash that
may be as devastating to America as the 1929 Crash, the Sixties
Nifty-Fifty boom, the dot-com crash of 2000 preceding a 30-month
recession, and $10 trillion market losses in the 2008 bank-credit
collapse.
Here are the 10 high-risk bubbles GMO sees as
warning signals that another costly crash is dead ahead:
1. This-time-is-never-different bubble
Throughout history, market mania is
“rationalized with the argument that history is no longer a
reliable guide to the future.” In the 1920s it was a “new era.”
In the ‘90s a “new paradigm.” Today Wall Street’s doing it
again: “U.S. profit margins are currently at peak levels and the
profit share of GDP in the United States is more than two standard
deviations above its long-term mean based on data going back to the
1920s.”
2. Moral-hazard bubble
“Speculative
bubbles tend to form when market participants believe that financial
risk has been underwritten by the authorities.” Remember the
“Greenspan Put:” In the late 1990s Wall Street was convinced the
“Fed would support falling markets.” Greenspan “wasn’t going
to act against the bubble in technology stocks.” Fed policy hasn’t
changed much, they “put a floor under asset prices, encouraging
investors to take on more risk.” As a result, household wealth has
“rebounded to a near-record level of 472% of GDP, nearly 100% above
its long-term mean.” And today, banks still expect “perpetually
low interest
rates.”
3. Fed’s 24/7 easy-money bubble
Chancellor
tells us: “Great speculative bubbles have generally been
accompanied by periods of low interest
rates.”
For over a decade Greenspan’s policies “inflated the U.S. housing
bubble.” Then after the 2008 banking collapse, Bernanke’s cure
was “more of the same,” while “real interest rates have been
maintained at negative levels.” In addition, quantitative easing
kept long-term rates artificially low, inflating home prices and
growth-stock valuations, further inflating high-risk asset bubbles.
4. Perpetual growth bubble
Back in the ‘90s dot-com bubble, tech stocks
were experiencing rapid “S-curve” growth while investors were
“encouraged to value the “real options” of Internet stocks from
future income streams yet to be conceived. Same today. Hot stocks in
social networking, electric cars, biotechnology, Internet, “have
been boosted by similar wishful thinking.” Warning, throughout
history, future earnings estimates kill future bubbles.
5. Zero-valuation asset bubbles
Since
the 17th century Dutch tulip mania, “most speculative markets”
have had no income to anchor a speculator’s imagination. Today’s
electronic age makes it worse.Bitcoin “soared
by 5,500%” in 2013. In fact, Chancellor warns most “recent stock
market darlings — Netflix, Facebook,
Tesla, and Twitter — have little or nothing in the way of profits.”
Even with margins dropping, Amazon was up nearly 60% in 2013. It’s
still “the poster child for a market more obsessed with growth than
profitability.”
6. ‘Gilded Age’ bubble revival
Throughout history “asset price bubbles are
associated with quick fortunes, rising inequality, and luxury
spending booms,” warns Chancellor; excessive, out-of-control
“conspicuous consumption.” Since the 2009 bottom, the art bubble,
“evident before the financial crisis, has returned.” Example, a
Jeff Koons “Balloon Dog” sculpture auctioned at $58 million, even
though it was one of five he had made in a factory. “The same
month, a painting by Francis Bacon sold for $142 million, the highest
price ever paid for any work at auction.” Yes, the Gilded Age of
the late ‘20s is back. More bad news.
7. New junk-bond-mania bubble
Another dangerous trend: “Manic markets are
often marked by a decline in credit standards,” says Chancellor.
The real estate bubble exploded Wall Street’s love of subprime
mortgages, “but it hasn’t diminished the appetite for low quality
U.S. credit.” Today investors are buying “the lowest yields for
junk bonds in history.” Quality is deteriorating. “Last year,
nearly two out of three corporate bond issues carried a junk rating.”
Even Fed boss Yellen has “expressed concern about the manic
leveraged loan market.”
8. ‘Irrational Exuberance’ bubble sequel
Yes, ‘90s “Irrational Exuberance” is
roaring back: “Market sentiment have become very elevated over the
past year.” The IPO market “has become particularly speculative.”
First-day trading on new IPOs were up an average 20%. “Twitter rose
74% on the day it came to the market.” Yet, most of the recent IPOs
not only had no profits, many, especially biotechs, haven’t “even
got around to generating anything by way of revenue.”
9. Corporate-insider-trading bubble
“Other sentiment measures have been telling
the same story” according to Chancellor’s GMO research team:
Corporate insider trading, a “reasonably good indicator of
management’s view on the intrinsic value of their companies”
recently “climbed to near record levels.” Equity mutual funds
“picked up lately.” And “margin debt as a share of GDP is close
to its peak level.” All scary stuff.
10. Composite market sentiment index
GMO’s composite index of 20 sentiment
indicators has “reached an extreme level, fast approaching two
standard deviations above its long-run average.” Since the 1950s
that extreme has only been exceeded twice, in 1968 during the “Great
Garbage Market” and in the late ‘90s dot-com mania.
“Great bubbles tend to coincide with strong
credit growth,” says Chancellor. So far that’s missing. We need
it before a “full-blown stock market bubble,” and right now “the
credit cycle is not close to a peak.” So unfortunately, the Fed
will probably passively watch while a “full-blown stock market
bubble” builds to critical mass.
In short, Yellen will do exactly what Greenspan
and Bernanke did earlier … fail to plan ahead … passively endure
more irrational exuberance mania … waiting for the ticking time
bomb to blow up … before finally stepping in … cleaning up their
mess … again … bailing out incompetent banks … while letting
the taxpayers suffer through the third major crash this century…
third recession … third megatrillion loss of Main Street’s
retirement market cap.
But beware, while as yet GMOs market sentiment
indicators don’t provide “a sure-fire signal that the U.S. stock
market is about to collapse,” investors “shouldn’t take much
comfort from this.” This cocktail of valuations, sentiment and
global macro trends has been quite accurate in “forecasting future
equity returns.”
Bottom line: “Anyone who bought U.S. stocks
in the past when sentiment was at today’s elevated level, lost
money.”
So
prudent investors please listen, very, very closely: It doesn’t
matter whether the markets crash or merely suffer a major correction,
GMO is warning us the S&P
500 has
a high probability of falling to “negative real returns over
one-year, three-year, and seven-year periods.” And that sure sounds
like another way of saying a major crash is dead ahead.
Paul B. Farrell is a MarketWatch columnist
based in San Luis Obispo, Calif. Follow him on Twitter @MKTWFarrell.
On Closer Look, the April Jobs Report Was In Fact a Disaster
About that jobs report.
Upon closer inspection, the report was a total
disaster. You wouldn’t know this from the financial media’s
coverage, but it was.
The establishment survey shows a gain of
288,000 jobs last month. However, the household survey shows that
that the economy lost 73,000 jobs in April.
This is critical. The household survey does not
allow for “duplication of individuals,” meaning that if someone
holds more than one job, they’re only counted once. In contrast, if
someone is working multiple low paying jobs, every single job will be
counted in the establishment survey.
Put it this way. If you go from one solid full
time job to working as a waiter, cab driver, and tossing pizzas, the
establishment survey will show that the economy created TWO jobs (one
job lost plus three started= two jobs net) whereas the household
survey will show NO growth (one person lost a job and started working
elsewhere).
With this in mind, you should be paying
attention to the household survey. The household survey shows 73,000
jobs were LOST. This negates the claim that 288,000 were created.
Aside from this oddity, we find that 806,000
people left the labor force. Moreover, reentrants (folks returning to
the labor force after being unemployed) fell 417,000. And new
entrants (folks entering the labor force for the first time) fell
126,000.
So the number of people in the labor force fell
as did the number of people returning to the labor force and the
number of folks entering the labor force for the first time.
To continue reading today’s article…
Phoenix Capital Research
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)