Swiss - Negative rates
In the past [even the recent past] investors have often 'parked'
their funds in a 'safe-haven' currency, when fears about the dollar
or other currencies rose. The leading candidates have always been the
Swiss Franc and the Yen, with gold, in the last three years usually
being excluded, because of its declining trend against the dollar and
the limited amount of stock relative to the availability of these
currencies. While gold's trend seems to have changed to the upside
now, the developed world is still 'out of gold'.
But gold has never forfeited its role as a 'safe-haven' for long. It
is distinguished by the fact that there is no lasting link between
gold and national governments and their national currencies. What
gold has always had is the respect and the belief that it is money
'in extremis'. For governments, through institutions to individuals,
gold is always money, even between enemies.
In the last 40 years and more, the world led by the U.S., has sought
to sideline gold as money, but inevitably it has proved its worth,
most notably when currency crises appear. The success the dollar has
had in these four decades has been largely due to two factors:
-
It is riveted to oil as the only currency with which oil could be bought.
-
It has the largest economy in the world, until now, as China appears to be moving into that place.
But as 2014 closed and a volatile, dramatic 2015 and 2016 entered our
lives, this is changing. With oil at less than half its peak value
today, only half the dollars that were used in the past for oil are
being used now. Add to this that payments for oil in currencies other
than the dollar, particularly by China, are being made. This is
massively reducing the need for the dollar, globally. All theses
excess dollars will become redundant, but the impact of this has yet
to be seen or appreciated.
Euro Crisis masking the dangers
With the euro crises throwing a smokescreen over the dollar picture,
as euros are exchanged for the U.S. dollar or through the 'carry
trade' borrowed and sent into high yielding emerging market
currencies, the dollar looks as though it is a strong currency.
Markets, market players and commentators tend to be myopic, focussed
on short-term profits and only distracted when larger issues actually
arrive. This is what's happening now.
We feel that what is happening now on foreign exchanges is an early
signal of much bigger issues that will appear in the next couple of
years.
Now we will look at the traditional 'safe-haven' currencies of the
Swiss Franc and the Yen to see just why currencies could only act as
'safe-haven' for a short time, while the monetary system remained
free of fundamental crises, such as the ones we see now and on the
horizon:
The Yen - The Yen hit its peak when it
stood at 76 to the U.S. dollar before the leading source of energy
[nuclear] was discarded and replaced by imported fuel.
As Japan's population ages and spending habits become conservative,
the real function of a currency has become apparent. It is used to
allow the local economy to function smoothly as the only local means
of exchange. Internationally, it is used as a basis for international
trade and investment. As such, it functions well
when the economy and Balance of Payments is healthy.
But when the Balance of Payments and the economy fail to function
well, it hurts the international value of the currency as we have
seen as Abenomics kicked in to lead Japan and the Yen into the
future.
More importantly it now defines the trade competitiveness of the
nation. Hence, the exchange rate itself, inevitably, is managed to
the nation's benefit and not that of its citizens or its own
integrity. Its integrity as a measure of value has been abandoned
alongside its role as a 'safe haven'.
While the G-20 agreed that nations would not purposely weaken their
exchange rates, the stark realities of today have overwhelmed these
commitments and will continue to do so 'where deemed necessary'.
Translated, that means it is now OK to weaken ones currency in the
interests of the nation's export competitiveness. As most currencies
follow this line and enter into the 'race to the bottom', any
advantage to a nation becomes short-term as the one against whom the
advantage was gained then does the same.
Today's exchange rate of the Yen is 118 to the dollar a 55% fall from
its recent peak. This fall is far bigger than the fall in the Ruble,
albeit the Yen fell over a longer period of time. The fact that it
has taken longer is OK as it can be absorbed in trade over that time.
This makes the policy more palatable? The consequences of such
myopia will focus on confidence. Confidence is the only ingredient
that makes a currency viable and a quality that if lost takes a
currency with it.
Hence the Yen is no longer a currency 'safe-haven'.
The Swiss Franc
The Swiss franc has been a hallowed currency 'safe-haven' for
generations, consistent with the earned image of Switzerland as a
'safe-haven' for foreigners assets and a nation that will fight to
protect these investors. The events of the last three years have cost
the Swiss dearly wiping out the confidence it had gained over the
previous century. As of now, at least 10% of the Swiss economy
depends upon the banking/asset management industry built up over this
time.
But the rest of the economy doesn't rely on this image. As a
world-respected manufacturer, Switzerland needs an exchange rate that
supports its international trade competitiveness, most importantly
against the euro, its main trading partner.
One would have thought that the two aspects of the Swiss economy
could co-exist together easily. But when pressure on the global
monetary system mounts, they can't.
The pressure on the Swiss Franc has been heavy in the last three
years when the Swiss National Bank [SNB] took severe action to hold
the 'Swissy' to euro at a ceiling of 1.20 to guard Switzerland's
exchange rate against the euro without even contemplating the
possibility that the world's second most important currency could
weaken so dramatically and so quickly from its peak against the
dollar.
The pressures proved too much last week and to the great surprise of
the whole world the 'Swissy' was unpegged! As we look around at the
damage the Swiss National Bank caused by 'unpegging' from the euro
and now linking it to a 'trade weighted basket of currencies',
including the U.S. dollar, we see once more, national interests
elevated far above those of the people using the 'Swissy' both inside
and out of Switzerland.
Perhaps you are thinking that the 'Swissy' can once more serve as a
'safe-haven' currency. A look at the intentions of the SNB in now
linking the Swissy to the 'basket of currencies', is to keep the
Swiss Franc down against them. This means that the SNB will continue
to intervene in the foreign exchanges and hold it down against these
other currencies.
So it will not return to 'safe haven' status, as we are now seeing in
the market place as it slowly slips down against gold and other
currencies. In addition, the Swiss National Bank has imposed an
interest rate of -0.75% on sight deposit account balances at the SNB.
In an effort to relieve the upward pressure on the Swiss franc, from
22 January the SNB will charge an interest rate of 0.75% on account
balances above a certain threshold held with it by banks and other
financial institutions. But will this work?
In what can only be described as a break in the integrity of the
Swiss National Bank, a week before unpegging the Swiss Franc, the SNB
reaffirmed its commitment to the minimum exchange rate of
CHF-EUR1.20, and "will continue to enforce it with the utmost
determination", they said. Further they said, "It remains the key
instrument to avoid an undesirable tightening of monetary conditions
resulting from a Swiss franc appreciation. Over the past few days, a
number of factors have prompted increased demand for perceived
'safe-haven' investments. The SNB is prepared to purchase foreign
currency in unlimited quantities and to take further measures, if
required."
And now?
The end of Currency 'Safe-havens'
The very concept of a currency acting as a 'safe-haven' has now been
destroyed by the actions of the currencies held up a one before. This
reputation will not change because no country can afford to let it
do so without mortally wounding its exports. It is hoped that the
monetary system will survive a long time despite the undermining of
the value of currencies. The loss of confidence in the currencies can
go to the point of collapsing it because it is a currency managed by
people who have differing agendas to the one that demands a solid
value for their money. As examples of this in the past we look at how
a currency is still used in a local economy while it is collapsing.
Please note that governments impose it use on an unwilling public until
it has collapsed.
We repeat, when a currency collapses internally, governments force
its citizens to use it in day-to-day transactions until it becomes
practically impossible to use it.
-
In the Weimar Republic after the first World War the German Mark fell from 4.63: $1 to 4.63 billion: $1.
Germans were going around with wheelbarrows to transport the
money needed for day to day transactions. Workers, when paid
would rush to the gates of the factory and threw their money
to wives who raced to the shops to buy whatever they could as
prices rose.
One story has it that a person left their money in a bag on a
bicycles outside a shop and when they returned the bag and
bicycle was gone and the money left on the pavement.
Nevertheless it took the total collapse of the currency
before the central bank changed the currency to the
Rentenmark, a currency issued against property [that could
not be printed]. By this time the middle and upper classes of Germany
had been wiped out financially [in the nation's interests].
-
In Zimbabwe, After the Z$: $1 U.S. traded at 1:1 it took Z$70,000
just to catch a bus to work late in the collapse of that
dollar in Harare. Now in Zimbabwe, the U.S. dollar is used,
in a shattered economy with 95% unemployment. But again for
the benefit of the government the Z$ was used right through
until it was completely unacceptable as a currency [in the
national interests] It even persisted with notes that had an
expiry date.
-
In a tried and tested manner over the life of currencies, gold
has always held international value. A Zimbabwean could go to
Mongolia and get the world price for his gold. Not so with
the Z$. The author has a Z$100,000,000,000,000 note in his
desk that is worth less than a sheet of toilet paper.
Such is the history of fiat currencies and will be in the future when the games governments play reach their climax.
The U.S. $ is now in the position of being the retreat from other
currencies, because the world's currencies are the branches off the
tree-trunk of the dollar. But the dollar itself is under siege too.
The Treasury department has made it clear that it does not want to
see a strong dollar! It too must guard its international trade
competitiveness by retraining a strong dollar. At the moment it is
silent on this, but for how long?
Thus we have two opposing flows in the U.S. dollar:
-
The inflow of dollars sold as they are excess to requirements and
-
The newly bought flows of dollars back to the U.S. as other
currencies fail to provide sufficient safety for investors.
The pressures on the dollar will take time to come to fruition and
will be signaled by the failure of other currencies [such as the
euro] and by the stumbling of the monetary system itself first.
Can the dollar collapse?
At the moment the dollar is the strongest of the world's currencies
and is reflecting that in its exchange rates. But this is relative
strength as the dollar will, if push comes to shove be the last
currency standing, even if it is itself inherently weak. It will be
used as there is no alternative to it in the Western world. [That's
why China is trying to free itself from dependence on the dollar and
be able to stand alone.]
If the dollar collapses it will be the last currency to collapse,
after the breakdown of the monetary system itself. Even if the Yuan
can stand alone, the developed world will not be permitted to
exchange all other currencies for the Yuan. So no matter what the
state of the dollar is, it will be used in the developed world.
Then, exchange rates will not be the measure of the dollar. When that
happens, once more, the dollar, relative to other currencies will
still look strong. The lack of confidence in currencies [and the
dollar] will be reflected in volatility, instability and uncertainty,
with many 'hallowed' currency standards being abandoned along the
way. In turn, the Treasury and equity markets alongside institutions
in the financial markets will stumble and fall. But everyone will be
trying to turn to items that will be effective measures of value and
means of exchange.
Among these internationally, precious metals will be at the head of
the list. While individuals and institutions will turn to these
markets, so will governments. As happened in 1933, governments will
take such items to add credibility to their currencies and be able to
say that the banking system will be 'lending against good assets'!
At that time the price of gold will not be measured by the dollar,
but gold will measure the dollar.
Until that day comes we can expect growing currency
volatility and to the extent the precious metal markets allow, a
turning to gold and then silver slowly but surely!
Gold Forecaster regularly covers all fundamental and Technical aspects of the gold price in the weekly newsletter. To subscribe, please visit www.GoldForecaster.com
By Julian D. W. Phillips
Gold-Authentic Money
Copyright 2014 Authentic Money. All Rights Reserved.
Julian Phillips - was receiving his qualifications to join the London
Stock Exchange. He was already deeply immersed in the currency turmoil
engulfing world in 1970 and the Institutional Gold Markets, and writing
for magazines such as "Accountancy" and the "International Currency
Review" He still writes for the ICR.
What is
Gold-Authentic Money all
about ? Our business is GOLD! Whether it be trends, charts, reports or
other factors that have bearing on the price of gold, our aim is to
enable you to understand and profit from the Gold Market.
Disclaimer - This document is not
and should not be construed as an offer to sell or the solicitation of
an offer to purchase or subscribe for any investment. Gold-Authentic
Money / Julian D. W. Phillips, have based this document on information
obtained from sources it believes to be reliable but which it has not
independently verified; Gold-Authentic Money / Julian D. W. Phillips
make no guarantee, representation or warranty and accepts no
responsibility or liability as to its accuracy or completeness.
Expressions of opinion are those of Gold-Authentic Money / Julian D. W.
Phillips only and are subject to change without notice.
© 2005-2014
http://www.MarketOracle.co.uk - The Market Oracle is a
FREE Daily Financial Markets Analysis & Forecasting online publication.